It's a good time to be a football fan in Michigan. Their biggest college team just won a National Championship this year for the first time since 1997 and the Lions are one win away from the Super Bowl after winning two playoff home games for the first time in over three decades. The success of the Lions in particular has a lot of the national spotlight on the city of Detroit, which, so far, has been met with a mixed bag of emotions from those that live there. On one hand, the Lions' success has been a long time coming, and the things that Dan Campbell and company are doing deserve to be celebrated within the context of the Lions' last three or four decades. On the other, their success has plenty of pundits – including, recently, ESPN's Stephen A. Smith – parroting the same, out-of-touch narratives that have been attached to Detroit for far too long.
Stephen A. Smith says Detroit was 'on a respirator as a city' before the Lions' success: pic.twitter.com/2ipP9yiKOR
— philip lewis (@Phil_Lewis_) January 22, 2024
"Detroit – phenomenal fanbase. Great city. Been through a lot," he said. "The downtown area? Big time. The stadium? Big time. But you go to other outskirts of the Detroit area, and it looks like a damn desert town. I mean, I'm sitting here wondering how the hell people are making money. It looks like a desert town. I'm looking at it and I'm like, 'what the hell is going on in this city?' And then you see the Detroit Lions and sort of reviving – they were on a respirator for crying out loud, just as a city. And what this franchise has done for that cit and state? You've got to go there to see what I'm talking about. Because when you get away from the downtown area, when you get away from the stadium, and you're just driving around? It's different, man. It's different. And so to know and see the kind of impact this is having? ... Right now, seeing what Detroit was, and what it has been revived into? Knowing that the Lions have everything to do with that? It extends beyond football, and it extends beyond the individual."
In Smith's defense, it does seem like he's trying to be complimentary. The Lions are one of the better, if not best, feel-good stories left across all four teams heading into Championship Weekend, but like Detroit Free Press writer Darren A. Nichols points out in a column about Smith's comments, Detroit residents are tired of hearing the same speech about how bad things got. And judging by the Twitter reactions to the clip, most people agree.
I can take you to nice neighborhoods, houses and bars/restaurants in any direction you point to that’s not downtown.
— James L. Edwards III (@JLEdwardsIII) January 23, 2024
Every major city has rough parts. Every single one. https://t.co/qIbvqgCIAS
I have been many places. I have been to very, very few places I’d rather live than Detroit. Read a book, man. Talk to somebody. Get a take that’s not from 2009. https://t.co/81g1x4bwDg
— kyle meinke (@kmeinke) January 23, 2024
"You go to other outskirts of the Detroit area it looks like a damn desert." 🙄 https://t.co/zo3yGJ7wGw
— Jay Davis (@JayDavis_1981) January 22, 2024
Very odd take . Detroit is a thriving city . Things have been aggressively improving. Could things be better ? Absolutely! But organizations and people here have been coming together to make that happen. Not too much on Detroit babe ❤️ https://t.co/juWCy6buNN
— WITH🩷 (@KristyLove__) January 22, 2024
SAS and all national pundits need to stop parroting old talking points. Stop acting like the ENTIRE city of Detroit is some Mad Max hellscape and only winning sports teams can rescue it. It’s tired. https://t.co/M1n9BzF4DP
— Jamal Spencer (@JamalSpencerTV) January 23, 2024
To Smith's – or the producer that was in charge of monitoring First Take's mentions – credit, he came back and worked to clarify the point that he was trying to make:
Stephen A. clarifies his comments, saying he was not "disrespecting the city of Detroit" and "wishes the folks there were treated better" pic.twitter.com/tiHchkNVi8
— philip lewis (@Phil_Lewis_) January 22, 2024
The oddsmakers are doubting Detroit too and you can take your shot at making them pay with house money at BetMGM! Just sign up, deposit $10 or more and then bet $5 or more on Lions vs. Niners. You'll instantly win $158 in bonus bets! Sign up for BetMGM today.