Skip to main content

An 'NFC South' rule could be coming for the NFL postseason (thanks to the Lions)

ByCandace Pedraza
Detroit Lions tight end Sam LaPorta (87) makes a catch against Carolina Panthers cornerback Akayleb Evans (29) during the second half at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte on Sunday, Oct. 4, 2026.
Detroit Lions tight end Sam LaPorta (87) makes a catch against Carolina Panthers cornerback Akayleb Evans (29) during the second half at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte on Sunday, Oct. 4, 2026. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Turns out, the NFC South might face some consequences for being downright disgraceful as of late.

The division, which currently features all four teams with a losing record - and the Carolina Panthers in first place with a 4-5 record - could end up with one squad hosting a Wild Card game in the postseason. Even if the winner of the NFC South ends up with a below-.500 record at the end of the year, just as the case was in 2025, they can host a team like the Detroit Lions or Minnesota Vikings, in theory.

This could be changing soon, though. According to ESPN's Dan Graziano, there are discussions picking back up in the league office about removing the opportunity for a sub-.500 team to host a postseason game, even if they won their division. This conversation, which began in 2025 thanks to a proposal from the Lions, is likely to continue with the division not looking like it'll be getting any better.

NFC South wouldn't be only division under scrutiny with this proposal

Whiel the NFC South is the obvious target of this restructuring of postseason seeding and scheduling, it could impact any division in the future that maybe doesn't seem primed for continued success. The NFC East comes to mind immediately.

While the New York Giants are currently in first place in that division with a 5-3-1 record, it feels like they're constantly teetering on the edge of falling to .500 without Jaxson Dart, and with some inconsistent play from their defense at times. The Dallas Cowboys remain on their heels with a 4-6 record. That's...less than inspiring.

READ MORE: Another get-right game could be waiting for Lions’ secondary against Bucs

It lends itself to the argument for this proposal to go through this offseason. The NFC North is currently a juggernaut, arguably the best division in football, and one team within the division could hypothetically finish up far over .500 and end up on the road for a Wild Card game against the Giants, or Panthers, or Bucs. That's just not right.

How proposal could lessen competition in struggling divisions

One downside to this proposal is that you won't see the kind of wild finishes to the season that we saw last year - namely, watching the Panthers and Bucs duking it out for the first place slot in the NFC South, with Carolina earning the divisional title at 8-9 and hosting the Los Angeles Rams in the Wild Card. The Rams, by the way, were 12-5.

Of course, it was a thriller of a game, so it does feel a bit wrong to take away the opportunity for an upset out of the hands of Carolina, or Tampa Bay, or whomever comes out the NFC South just because of their record. It does lend itself to the drama of the postseason, after all.

It would also potentially remove the incentive for teams to be pushing until Week 18 to eke out a divisional title with a losing record. Without the promise of hosting a postseason game, and just the promise of a spot in the big dance, would teams be as competitive under this proposal?

With a second year about to provide us with another look at how the NFL's current structure benefits, or harms, the "final product," we should soon see if there remains any positives to take away from a battle of mid in the NFC South.

Add us as a preferred source on Google